Skip to content
Book a call
An open translucent glass case on a black background holds a paintbrush in one compartment and an adjustable wrench in the other.
← All Transmissions

Your ad account shows whether to hire a creative strategist or a media buyer first

Key takeaways

The creative strategist vs media buyer question comes down to where your Meta account is breaking, and its structure tells you first. If the campaigns, ad sets and ads are organized and named properly, the creative is the more likely problem, so check CTR, hook and hold rate, average play time, engagement and the CPA of your top spenders. If the account is full of mixed objectives, confusing ad sets and daily firefighting, start with a media buyer. Plenty of accounts need both.

The account tells you which one you need

When Meta results stall, brand owners often ask whether to hire a media buyer or get help with the creative. The answer to the creative strategist vs media buyer question is usually in your ad account.

I look at an account's structure before any metric. If it's organized and named properly, there's some method to the madness, and the problem is more likely the creative. If it's a mess and the team is always firefighting, it's more likely the media buying. Then I confirm it with data.

What a media buyer and a creative strategist do

A media buyer runs the ad account. That means the campaign structure, budgets, bids, targeting and tracking, plus the daily calls on where the money goes.

A creative strategist decides what the ads say and show. Creative strategy covers the customer research, the reasons to buy, the concepts and briefs, and the results that shape the next round. If you're pricing the role, what a creative strategist costs compares freelance, in-house and agency options.

Look at the account's structure first

Are the campaigns, ad sets and ads named properly?

Names that say what each campaign is for, and which concept and format each ad carries, show someone runs the account with a plan. Default names mean nobody can say what's running, or why a winner won.

Do the campaigns share one goal?

If you sell online, running traffic, engagement and sales campaigns side by side with no clear reason leaves much of the budget chasing something other than a sale.

Does every ad set have a job?

Ad sets should split the budget for a reason, such as testing against scaling. Meta says that when you create many ads and ad sets, its system learns less about each one, which can keep them in the learning phase.

Is someone planning, or is everyone firefighting?

Ads switched on and off daily, budgets changed every morning and a new campaign for every bad week all point to firefighting. Ads Manager's Activity history shows who changed what and when, including changes made by automated rules. If Black Friday is close and nothing is planned yet, our guide to last-minute Black Friday ads shows what you can still make.

Creative signals and media buying signals

I don't give benchmarks for any of these. Compare your own ads over the same dates.

Hook rate and hold rate aren't Meta's own metric names. Hook rate is the share of a video ad's impressions that turn into at least three seconds of viewing. Hold rate is the share of those viewers who keep watching, often measured as ThruPlays divided by 3-second video plays.

Creative signals to check
MetricWhat it showsWhat a problem looks like
Click-through rate (CTR)Whether the ad gives people a reason to clickFew people click on most of your ads
Hook rateWhether the opening of a video stops peopleMost videos lose people in the first three seconds
Hold rateWhether the body of a video keeps people after the hookPeople stop for the hook, then leave before the product appears
Average play timeHow long people watch a video on averagePeople leave long before the offer or the call to action
Spend and CPA on your top adsWhether the ads Meta spends most on are making you moneyYour biggest spenders sit above your profitable CPA
Likes, shares and commentsWhether people care enough to reactThe ads take spend but get almost no reactions

I also read the likes, shares and comments on each ad, because in my experience that engagement tends to push the creative further organically.

On the media buying side, CBO, now called Advantage+ campaign budget, moves one budget between ad sets, while ABO gives each ad set its own budget. Meta says the right budget strategy depends on your goals, so I want to hear the reason behind the choice.

Interest targeting is another tell, because Meta treats interests as suggestions by default and can reach beyond them when you optimize for conversions. Automated rules can pause ads or change budgets on their own, and crazy rules kill ads before they've had a fair chance.

Media buying signals to check
Metric or settingWhat it showsWhat a problem looks like
CPMWhat you pay for every 1,000 impressionsCPMs keep rising with no seasonal reason
CBO or ABOHow the budget is split between ad setsNobody can explain why the budget sits where it does
TargetingHow the account looks for buyersAd sets built on stacks of interests
Automated rulesWhat changes without a person decidingRules that pause ads or cut budgets after a day or two

What to do with what you find

What you find and what to do next
What you seeWhat it points toWhat to do next
A tidy account where the biggest spenders sit above your profitable CPAThe creativeBrief new concepts with different reasons to buy
Weak hook rates on most videosThe openingsTest new hooks on your strongest concepts
Strong hooks but weak hold ratesThe body of the adsRework the script and the edit after the hook
A good CTR but few salesWhat happens after the clickCheck the site and the tracking before you change the ads
Spend with almost no likes, shares or commentsThe messageGo back to customer research for new angles
Campaigns with mixed objectives and overlapping ad setsThe media buyingCombine campaigns and ad sets so each one has a clear job
Interest stacks, crazy rules or daily firefightingThe media buyingBring in a media buyer who can explain every setting
A messy account and weak creative metricsBothClean up the structure while new ads are in production

If your ads get clicks but few sales, start with our guide to Facebook ads getting clicks but no sales. If the creative needs work, new concepts beat new versions of the same ad, as I explain in the article on creative concepts vs variations. Our guides to UGC agency vs DIY and AI ad generator vs agency show what it takes to produce the new ads.

When you need both

Fix the structure while the new ads are being made, so they launch into an account where you can trust each creative test.

With our Creative Strategy service, we do the research, write the concepts and scripts, and make the finished ads. Your media buyer can keep running the account while we review performance with view access, or we can run it as part of the engagement. If only the media buying needs help, Meta Ads Management gives you campaign setup, creative testing, tracking, optimization and reporting while your team keeps making the ads.

Get a free growth audit

I'm personally involved in every account, leading the day-to-day strategy and major parts of the execution, with no account manager in between. Working with us starts with a free growth audit that shows where creative or media support would make the biggest difference.

Book a call to go through your account. Our prices are on the services page.

Putting it into practice

  • Look at the account's structure before you hire anyone.
  • Confirm it by comparing your own ads with each other over the same dates.
  • When both need work, fix the structure while the new ads are being made.

Frequently asked questions

Should I hire a media buyer or a creative strategist first?

Check your ad account first. If the campaigns, ad sets and ads are organized and named properly, start with a creative strategist. If the account has mixed objectives, confusing ad sets and daily firefighting, start with a media buyer.

Can one person do creative strategy and media buying?

Yes, and plenty of small teams combine them. Just make sure someone clearly owns each job. Our Creative Strategy service includes running your account when you want us to.

What is a good hook rate or click-through rate?

There's no single number for every brand, because both move with the format, placement, audience and offer. Compare your own ads over the same dates and study the ones that clearly beat the rest.

What is the difference between CBO and ABO?

CBO, now called Advantage+ campaign budget, lets Meta move one campaign budget between ad sets, while ABO gives each ad set its own budget. Meta's guide to campaign and ad set budgets suggests ad set budgets when you want to control what each ad set spends.

Do you offer media buying on its own?

Yes. Meta Ads Management covers campaign setup, creative testing, tracking, optimization and reporting while your team keeps making the ads. Our prices are on the services page. To talk it through, book a call.