
Choose a creative strategy agency by how it thinks, not by its showreel
Key takeaways
To choose a creative strategy agency for a DTC brand, rate every agency on your shortlist on the same seven points: research, concepts and briefs, production and formats, turnaround, testing and reporting, who does the work and fit. Ask to see a real research summary and brief, and meet the person who will write yours. Then use the first month as proof of the process, because sales results take longer to judge.
A good agency shows its thinking in the first month
It's tempting to choose a creative strategy agency from its showreel, but a reel only shows finished ads. It doesn't show the research behind them, how many ads it took to find a winner or how long the next round takes, and those are the parts you pay for every month.
So judge each agency on how it thinks and how fast it makes ads. After a good first month, you've read the research on your customers, approved concepts that came from it and seen finished ads go live, and you know who writes your briefs. If you're a DTC (or D2C) founder with two to four agencies on a shortlist, this is how I'd compare them.
What to prepare before you talk to agencies
An agency can only show you how it thinks if it has something real to think about. Have these ready before the first call.
- One goal for the next three months, such as a lower cost per purchase from new customers or a product launch.
- A budget range for both the fee and the ad spend, because your Meta budget decides how many concepts you can test properly.
- Your top ads by spend from the last few months, a few that flopped and any customer research you have, such as reviews.
- View access to your ad account, so the agency can look before the call and come with specific questions.
How to choose a creative strategy agency in five steps
1. Shortlist two to four agencies
Look for agencies that plan and make Meta ads for DTC brands. Our list of the best creative strategy agencies says who each one suits. If nobody on your team produces ads, check that each agency makes them too, or you'll end up hiring editors on top, as I explain in what a creative strategist costs. Two to four agencies give you enough to compare without the calls blurring together.
2. Look past the showreel
Ask for one case study that shows the research, the ads and the results. Then pick one ad and ask them to walk you through it: where the idea came from, what it tested, what happened and what they made next.
Our Paramedic Flash case study shows the kind of answer to look for. The research into reviews, competitors and student threads on Reddit pointed to one fear, freezing on a drug dose, and that fear shaped the strongest format, a scenario video that opens in the middle of an emergency. We produced 18 creatives across three formats, and 6 of them became consistent spenders. That 6 out of 18 tells you more about an agency than its best ad does.
You can also look up the brands from their case studies in the Meta Ad Library, which lists every active ad and the date each one started running. If the ads they showed you have been running for months, the brand is probably happy to keep paying for them.
3. Use the first call to test their thinking
Notice whether they looked at your ads and your site beforehand, and whether they ask about your customers before they talk about themselves. If the person on the call won't write your briefs, ask to meet the one who will. Then ask them to break down two or three of your current ads live, including one that stopped working, and listen to how they think it through. DTCMidas, an ecommerce operator on X, suggests this test for hiring an in-house strategist, to catch people who only copy ads they've seen.
4. Compare proposals on the same terms
Every agency counts its work differently, so line up the proposals on the same terms before you compare prices.
- How many concepts you get each month, and what counts as one. Ten versions of one message are still one concept.
- Which formats they make, how long a brief takes and how many rounds of revisions you get.
- Who runs the ad account, and which costs sit outside the fee, such as creator fees and ad spend.
- The minimum term, and who owns the finished ads.
5. Treat the first month as proof
Sign with the agency that scores best, on terms that don't lock you in before you've seen a month of work. Then check that month against the list further down.
A scorecard for comparing creative strategy agencies
Rate each agency strong, unclear or weak on every line, so the best pitch doesn't win by default.
| What to score | Ask to see | A strong sign | A warning sign |
|---|---|---|---|
| Research | A research summary from a past client, with the name removed | Customer words from reviews, comments or interviews, grouped into reasons to buy and reasons to hold back | Personas that could describe any brand, with no sources behind them |
| Concepts and briefs | A real brief and the concepts it came from | Each concept gives a different reason to buy, and each brief names the audience, the message and what the ad tests | One message in five formats, sold as five concepts |
| Production and formats | Finished ads in the formats you need | The team that writes the brief makes the statics, videos, UGC and AI video | Production handed to someone else, at an extra cost |
| Turnaround | The time from an approved brief to a finished ad | A clear answer for a single ad and for a batch | No dates, or weeks between rounds |
| Testing and reporting | A report from a past client | Results by concept, what was learned and what gets made next | Screenshots of ROAS with no next step |
| Who does the work | The person who will write your briefs | You talk to them directly, on calls or in a shared channel | An account manager passes messages back and forth |
| Fit | Work for brands like yours, and the contract | Works with your media buyer or runs the account, on terms you can live with | A long contract before you've seen a month of work |
For comparison, our turnaround can be 1 to 2 business days, depending on the complexity and the volume, and longer batches can be ready within the same week. I'm personally involved in every account, leading the day-to-day strategy and major parts of the execution, with no account manager in between, and we can join your Slack or WhatsApp.
Red flags when you hire a creative agency for Meta ads
When ecommerce brand owners on Reddit talk about agencies, the same warning signs come up again and again.
- The agency's best results came from very different brands. One fashion brand owner noticed that the strong ROAS figures agencies showed often came from brands with much cheaper products.
- A senior person sold the deal and a junior did the work. One brand owner's ad account went to a junior media buyer who was handling 14 other clients.
- The designers followed instructions, but nobody led the creative. A DTC skincare co-founder got “very little actual strategy or creative direction” from their agency.
- The agency switched off ads that were already working. That happened to a DTC toy brand and a solo ecommerce founder soon after their agencies started, so ask on the first call which of your current ads they'd keep running.
- Hard questions got a vanity metric or a request for more time. One store owner kept hearing that a 3.5% click-through rate meant the ads were doing their job. Patience is fair in the first month, as long as they can show you the research and what each ad is testing.
What the first month should show you
Sales results take longer, but by the end of the first month you should see the process working.
- The research, in writing, with your customers' own words in it.
- Concepts that trace back to that research, each giving a different reason to buy.
- Briefs you approved before production started.
- Finished ads, delivered by the dates they promised.
- A first read of the results by concept, such as which ads stopped people, which got clicks and which ones Meta chose to spend on.
- A plan for month two that follows from those results.
Don't judge the sales yet. Meta says ad sets in the learning phase are less stable and usually have a higher CPA. For how the work runs month after month, read what a creative strategy agency does.
If the first month doesn't show it
Say so early, and be specific. “We haven't seen the research yet” or “these five concepts are one message” gives an agency something to fix in the next round. If that round has the same problem, move to the next agency on your scorecard. A month-to-month agreement makes that much easier, so ask for one before you sign.
The next step
Score your shortlist and book follow-up calls with the two agencies that come out on top. For general questions to ask any agency, use the list in our guide to choosing a Meta ads agency, which works for agencies anywhere.
If you'd like to put us through the same test, Fifth Dimension is a creative strategy agency for Meta ads. We do the research, write the concepts and briefs and produce the finished ads, and your media buyer can keep running the account or we can run it for you. Every engagement starts with a free growth audit, and our prices are on the services page. Book a call and bring your scorecard.
Putting it into practice
- Rate every agency on the same seven lines, and ask to see the work behind each answer.
- Meet the person who will write your briefs before you sign.
- Use the first month to check the process: the research, the concepts, the finished ads and the plan for month two.
Book a call

