Skip to content
Book a call
A glass sieve full of small star-shaped tokens stands above a blank sheet, where three stars have fallen through, on a black background.
← All Transmissions

How to turn customer reviews into a creative brief creators can work from

Key takeaways

To turn customer reviews into a creative brief, copy useful lines word for word and tag each one as the problem, what the customer tried, the solution, the outcome or a doubt. Count which ideas repeat, pick one buyer and the problem they mention most, and put their exact phrases into a one-page brief. The brief tells a creator or editor who the ad is for, what to say in plain language and what to show. It replaces guesswork with what customers wrote, though it can't guarantee a result, and the creator should still describe only their own experience.

Why reviews make better briefs than clever copy

Customer reviews are where buyers describe the problem, what they tried and what changed, often in words other buyers use too. When the same language comes up again and again, it's the most useful thing you can hand a creator. I'd take a line that keeps showing up in reviews over the cleverest headline anyone on the team can write.

Clever copy sounds like a brand talking. A UGC ad should sound like a peer, someone who had the same problem and describes it in plain words. Reviews let you stop guessing how customers talk, because you can use what they wrote.

Seth Godin has a short line for why peers matter. In his post Building blocks of marketing, he writes: “People like us do things like this” is the definition of culture. It's also one of the ideas he listed for his book This Is Marketing, in a post about what's inside it.

I treat it as a rule for writing briefs, not a promise about how viewers will react. If the viewer is meant to see someone like them on screen, the brief has to describe that person and their situation in words they'd use themselves. Your reviews are where you find those words.

What you need before you start

You need your reviews and one sheet to sort them in. Export every review you can, including the three and four star ones, because middle ratings often hold the most honest doubts. If you only have a few reviews, read reviews of competing products as well. Our guide to voice of customer research lists other places where buyers talk, such as Reddit and ad comments.

Copy each useful line into the sheet word for word, with a column that says where it came from. Don't tidy the grammar, and don't shorten lines into summaries yet. A summary such as “people love it” gives a creator nothing to say. They need the specific detail from the original review.

Sort reviews by problem, attempts and outcome

Sorting turns a pile of reviews into a short list of things customers keep saying. I tag every line, count the tags, and only then decide what the brief is about. User researchers call this thematic analysis. Nielsen Norman Group describes it as tagging observations and quotes with codes, and says a theme emerges when related findings come up again and again across people or sources.

How to sort customer reviews for a creative brief
  1. Copy

    Paste useful lines word for word, with the source beside each one.

  2. Tag

    Label each line as the problem, what they tried, the solution, the outcome or a doubt.

  3. Count

    Group lines that mean the same thing in different words, and count each group.

  4. Choose

    Pick one buyer and the problem that comes up most often for them.

  5. Pull

    Take that group's exact phrases into the brief.

Each tag feeds a different part of the brief.

  • The problem is how customers describe life before the product. It gives you the hook and tells the creator who they're talking to.
  • What they tried covers the fixes that let them down. It gives the ad context and shows why the product is different.
  • The solution is what the product did differently, in the customer's own plain words.
  • The outcome is what changed afterwards. It's the payoff, so keep it as specific as the review.
  • A doubt is anything that nearly stopped someone from buying. The ad should answer it, or at least not make it worse.

If a review shows who wrote it, note that too, such as someone buying for themselves or as a gift. One product can have several kinds of buyer, each with their own problem, and the choose step only works if you can tell them apart.

A repeat means the same idea, not the same words. Two customers can describe one problem in completely different ways, and both lines belong in the same group. One vivid review isn't a pattern, though, so count before you build a brief around it.

The creative brief template

A brief built from reviews should fit on one page. A creator or editor should be able to read it once and know who the ad is for, what to say and what to show. Our definition of a creative brief covers what every brief needs, and this template adds where each field comes from in your reviews.

Creative brief template built from customer reviews
FieldWhat to writeWhere it comes from
The viewerOne person, their situation and how they'd describe itThe problem lines that repeat most
The problem, in their wordsTwo or three exact phrases customers useProblem lines, copied word for word
What they triedThe fixes that let them down beforeLines about what they tried
What the product doesThe solution in plain words, with no brand languageSolution lines
The outcomeThe specific change customers describeOutcome lines
The doubt to answerThe worry that comes up most before buyingDoubt lines and middle ratings
Hook optionsTwo or three openings built from repeated phrasesProblem and outcome lines
What to showShots, settings and product moments that prove the pointDetails customers mention
ClaimsWhat the creator may say, and what they must not sayYour product facts and the proof behind each claim, not the reviews
What this ad testsOne line naming the reason to buy you're testingThe group you chose to brief

The last field matters most. It tells the creator and the editor why the ad exists, and it tells you what to look at when the results come in. The reason to buy is the ad's angle, and the hook options are different ways to open on it.

Keep the brief separate from the script. One brief can hold several scripts, such as different hooks for the same problem. If the hooks start pointing at different problems, write separate briefs, because those are different concepts. One practitioner on r/FacebookAds put it as a rule of thumb: angles come from reviews and support tickets, a new promise to a new person is a new angle, and the same promise with new visuals is a variation. Our guide to creative concepts vs variations explains the difference.

An illustrative example

This example is illustrative. The product category is invented, and the review lines below are made-up examples, not real reviews.

Imagine a DTC (or D2C) brand that sells a reusable pet hair remover for sofas and car seats. After sorting its reviews, the biggest group is about dog hair that won't come off fabric. Here are three made-up review lines from that group:

  • Made-up review line: “I was buying sticky rollers every week and the couch still looked furry.”
  • Made-up review line: “Two strokes and the hair rolls up into a ball. My black sofa looks black again.”
  • Made-up review line: “I didn't think it would work on the car seats, but it did.”

The first line covers what they tried and the problem. The second covers the solution and the outcome. The third is a doubt, answered by someone who had it. Here's how those lines fill part of the brief.

Illustrative brief excerpt (invented product, made-up review lines)
FieldFilled in
The viewerA dog owner with dark fabric furniture who is tired of hair on everything
The problem, in their words“The couch still looked furry”
What they triedSticky rollers, bought every week
What the product doesRolls the hair up into a ball in a few strokes, and you use it again and again
The outcome“My black sofa looks black again”
The doubt to answerWhether it works on car seats
Hook optionsOpen on a pile of used sticky roller sheets, or on a hair-covered black sofa
What to showBefore and after on the same cushion, filmed in one take
What this ad testsWhether owners tired of buying sticky rollers respond to a reusable fix

There's no slogan in this brief. The creator gets the words customers used and a clear job, and then says it in their own voice. If the finished ad says the product clears hair in a few strokes, though, that's a claim about the product, and the brand needs its own proof for it, whatever the reviews say.

Keep the creator's story true

Customer language shapes what the creator talks about. It doesn't give them experiences they never had.

A review tells you what one customer experienced. It can't substantiate an objective claim about the product or show what a typical buyer will get. The FTC's Endorsement Guides FAQ says the advertiser is responsible for substantiating objective product claims. It also says that when an endorsement describes specific results, people will usually read it as what they can expect too, and a line like “results not typical” doesn't change that. So use reviews for the language in the brief, and back every claim in the ad with your own evidence.

The creator should use the product and describe what happened for them. If the outcome in the brief doesn't happen for the creator, you want to know that before the ad runs. In the US, the FTC's Endorsement Guides FAQ says endorsers can't talk about their experience with a product they haven't tried. That's US guidance, so check the rules in each market where your ads run.

If you want real customers' words on screen, show them as reviews, and get permission to use them. A creator reading out a stranger's review as their own story is a fake testimonial. Our guide to AI UGC vs real creators explains why we advise against ads that pretend to be customers.

Check the brief before it goes out

Run these checks before a creator or editor sees the brief.

  1. Could someone read it once and say who the ad is for?
  2. Does every phrase in quotation marks trace back to a real review, with its source noted?
  3. Is it about one buyer and one problem?
  4. Is the language plain enough that a customer could have said it?
  5. Have the claims been checked against your product facts?
  6. Is there one line that says what the ad tests?

Then send it with the product. Our guide to managing UGC creators yourself covers everything that happens between the brief and the finished ad. Agree the usage rights and the rest of the scope at the same time, as our guide to how much UGC costs explains.

Use the rest of the sheet for the next brief

Your sorted sheet keeps working after the first brief. When results come in, compare them with the line that says what the ad tests. If people scrolled straight past, the hook rate will show it, and you can try another hook option from the same group before you give up on the idea. If a new ad hardly spends at all, read why new Meta ads don't get spend before you judge the brief.

The second biggest group becomes the next brief. A doubt that keeps coming up may deserve an ad of its own, built around the customers who had that doubt and bought anyway. Keep adding new reviews to the sheet and count again from time to time, because what customers say can change after a new product version or a new offer.

Where Fifth Dimension fits

Customer research is the first part of our Creative Strategy service. We read your reviews, competitors' ads and buyer conversations, and every concept we brief traces back to what customers said. I'm personally involved in every account, so each brief comes from someone who has read the research.

If you need creators to film the briefs too, UGC Management covers sourcing, scripts, filming and editing. To compare creator partners, see our list of UGC agencies for Meta ads. If you'd like help turning your reviews into briefs, book a call.

Putting it into practice

  • Copy review lines word for word, tag them as the problem, what they tried, the solution, the outcome or a doubt, and count the repeats.
  • Build each brief around one buyer and the problem customers mention most, in their own words.
  • Treat reviews as customer language, not proof. Back every product claim with your own evidence, and let the creator describe only their own experience.

Frequently asked questions

How many reviews do I need to write a brief?

There's no set number. You need enough to see the same problem come up more than once. If your own reviews are thin, add reviews of competing products and buyer conversations, as our guide to voice of customer research explains.

Can AI sort my customer reviews for me?

It can help you group and count lines. Check every phrase it picks against the original review, and keep the exact wording, because a summary loses the detail a creator needs.

What if most of my reviews just say they love the product?

Read the three and four star reviews, and the longer five star ones that describe life before the product. If that's still thin, read reviews of competing products, or ask new customers what they tried before they bought from you.

Can I use a review as proof that my product works?

No. A review shows what one customer experienced, not what a typical buyer gets. In the US, the FTC's Endorsement Guides FAQ says advertisers must substantiate objective product claims, and that ads showing specific results need proof the results are typical or a clear statement of what people generally get. Check the rules in your own market too.

Does Fifth Dimension write briefs from customer reviews?

Yes. Customer research is the first part of our Creative Strategy service, and every concept we brief traces back to what customers said. Book a call if you'd like help with yours.