
8 checks we run on every AI ad before it goes live
Key takeaways
AI ads usually go wrong in one of two places. Inside Meta, Advantage+ creative enhancements can change your ad after you upload it, so we almost always switch them off. Inside the video, a clip can glitch, a voice can change accent or a subtitle can stop matching the voiceover, so we check every AI ad against the brief before it goes live. Our checklist has eight checks: the enhancements are off, the ad entertains or helps without pretending to be real, the product looks right, the voiceover matches the script in one accent, the lip sync holds, there are no glitches or hallucinations, overlays and subtitles stay consistent, and nothing was added that the brief didn't ask for.
AI ads go wrong in two places
AI ads are all over Facebook and Instagram now, and a lot of them are easy to spot. People call the worst of them AI slop: ads that look generated and give nobody a reason to keep watching.
When an AI ad goes wrong, it usually happens in one of two places. The first is inside Meta, where AI enhancements can change your ad after you upload it. The second is inside the video itself, where a generation glitches, a voice changes accent halfway through or a subtitle stops matching what's being said.
This is the checklist we run on our AI ads before they go live. Every check is something you can see or hear, so anyone on your team who knows the brief can run it.
| Check | What to look or listen for |
|---|---|
| Meta's AI enhancements are off | Every creative enhancement in the ad setup, Advanced preview and Review defaults |
| It entertains or helps | A reason to watch that doesn't depend on people thinking it's real |
| The product looks right | The right label, packaging, colours and shape in every shot, and only the claims the brief approved |
| The voiceover matches the script | Every word and product name said right, in the same accent from start to finish |
| The lip sync holds | Mouths that match the words on every talking shot |
| No glitches or hallucinations | Warped hands, faces, products or text, and objects that change between frames |
| Overlays and subtitles are consistent | The same font, size and position throughout, with subtitles that match the voiceover |
| Nothing extra was added | No sound, music, scene or text that the brief didn't ask for |
Switch off Meta's own AI enhancements
The first check happens in Ads Manager, not in the edit. We almost always switch off Meta's AI creative enhancements, and it's one of the most important parts of our QA.
Meta calls them Advantage+ creative enhancements. Depending on the format and placement, they can change the visuals, audio and text of your ad. Meta's help page says the enhancements try to keep your core message, but "the media and text you upload may be adjusted." Some of them are also turned on by default.
We have no hands-on experience with Meta's AI features, because we never use them. The previews in Ads Manager were enough to put us off. When you look at what the enhancements would do to an ad, it's creative you would never approve for your account. We wouldn't upload those versions ourselves, so we don't let Meta make them for us.
Here's where to find the settings, according to Meta's Help Center. Meta moves these menus around, so check the preview of every ad before you publish it.
- While you set up the ad. In the ad creative, go to the enhancements step and turn off each one you haven't approved. Then open Advanced preview and check its Advantage+ creative tab, because some enhancements can only be turned off there.
- In Review defaults. Next to Advanced preview, Review defaults lists every creative feature that's on by default for that ad, including translations, related media and auto-generated formats, with a link to switch each one off.
- On ads that are already live. Select the ad, click Edit and open the Advantage+ creative section, which shows how many enhancements are on.
- In your ad account settings. Under Advertising settings, Creating ads and then Creative features, untick Test new creative features so features that are still in testing aren't applied to your campaigns. Meta says only eligible advertisers see this option.
Make it entertaining or useful, not fake
The second check is about the idea, and it decides whether the ad deserves to run at all. Every AI ad we make has to entertain in some way and give the viewer something useful.
We're not trying to claim realism, and we're not trying to make anything look like something it isn't. It's the same reason we rarely make AI UGC that pretends to be a real customer. Once you stop pretending an AI ad is real, it needs another reason for people to keep watching. That could be a scene that would be impossible to film, a funny take on a problem your customer knows well or a clear look at how the product works.
A simple test helps here. If everyone watching knew the ad was made with AI, would it still be worth their time? If the answer is no, a better render won't fix it. The concept needs work, and that's a job for creative strategy, not the edit. Our guide to creative concepts vs variations explains how we decide what message each ad carries.
Being upfront also fits how Meta handles AI in ads. Meta adds an AI info label to ads made or edited with its own generative AI tools, and to ads where it detects third-party AI tools through industry-standard metadata such as C2PA. In some regions, including Europe, California, New York, India and Taiwan, advertisers can also disclose AI use themselves. Ads about social issues, elections or politics must disclose any photorealistic image, video or realistic-sounding audio made or edited with AI.
Check the finished ad against the brief
The rest of the checklist asks one question: does the finished ad match the brief? The creative brief is the standard. If something in the ad isn't in the brief, or something in the brief isn't in the ad, it isn't ready.
This matters more with AI video ads than with filmed ones, because every clip, voice line and caption is generated on its own, so a good first clip doesn't mean the next one will be right. We watch every AI ad on a phone at full speed, once with sound and once without, then go through these six checks.
We generate our footage, voiceovers and music in Magnific and edit them in Claude Code with ffmpeg. I explain that setup in how I edit our ads with an agentic video editor. The checks are the same whatever tools you use.
The product looks right
Generated footage can warp labels and packaging, so check the product in every shot, not just the first one. The label, packaging, colours and shape should match your real product and the references in the brief. Any claim on screen or in the voiceover should be one the brief approved and the brand can support.
The voiceover says the script, in one accent
Listen to the whole ad with the script open. Every word should match, and product names, prices and offers need to be said correctly. Then listen to the voice itself. The accent should stay the same from the first line to the last, because lines generated in separate takes don't always sound like the same person.
The lip sync holds on every talking shot
If an AI model speaks on camera, watch each talking shot at full speed and then slowed down. The mouth should match every word, especially on sounds like p, b and m, where the lips have to close. A mouth that's slightly late is enough to make the whole ad feel off.
No glitches or hallucinations in any generation
A hallucination is anything the model made up that shouldn't be there. Go through every generated clip and pause on the parts that usually break: hands, faces, the product, any text in the scene and anything that moves. Look for objects that change shape between frames, extra fingers, warped packaging and people in the background who don't look right.
Overlays and subtitles stay consistent
If AI helped edit the video, check every overlay and subtitle. The font, size, colour and position should stay the same from start to finish. Subtitles should match the voiceover word for word, spell product names correctly and stay clear of the parts of the screen that Reels and Stories cover. Even when an agent builds the captions, we watch every export ourselves.
Nothing added that the brief didn't ask for
Generation and editing tools sometimes add things on their own. Listen for music, sound effects or background voices nobody asked for, and watch for extra scenes, logos or on-screen text. If the brief didn't ask for it, it comes out.
Who should run the checks
If you make AI ads in-house, run this checklist on every ad, not just the first one in a batch. Give the job to one person who has read the brief and can say clearly what's wrong, with a timestamp for each fix. If a checked ad then gets clicks but no sales, work through our guide to Facebook ads getting clicks but no sales.
If you'd rather receive finished AI ads that have already been checked, that's what our AI Creative Production service does. You bring the approved concept and script. We handle the visual production, product detail and editing, check the finished work against your brief and cover the AI platform costs. You can see finished work in our ad portfolio and in the Madbury Road case study, where we made AI video ads for an outdoor furniture brand with no existing footage.
Putting it into practice
- Before you publish, open Review defaults and Advanced preview and switch off every enhancement you haven't approved.
- Watch every AI ad on a phone with the brief and script open, once with sound and once without.
- Ask whether the ad would still be worth watching if everyone knew it was made with AI.
Book a call

